Compare the purchase first
Ask for the out-the-door price with taxes and fees itemized. Identify any optional service contract, protection package or other product and its individual price. Keep the old loan payoff and your trade-in allowance on separate lines so you can see the trade’s net contribution.
For each quote, record the amount financed, term, contract rate, APR, first-payment date, recurring payment and total of payments. A separate bank or credit union quote can give you another set of terms to compare for the same vehicle.
Use the payment as a cross-check
With a $30,000 principal, 7% contract rate and 60 monthly payments, a standard estimate is about $594 per month. If the dealer quotes about $616, financing roughly $1,100 more would explain that gap under the same rate and timing assumptions.
Read the written quote to see whether the difference comes from a changed loan amount, rate, first payment, fee or product. Ask the dealer to show how the estimate was calculated.
Compare the amount you would pay over the whole term
Add cash due up front to the scheduled payments for each offer. Compare trade-in terms and retained rebates too. When you compare a dealer promotion against an outside lender, use the price and incentive offered with each specific financing option.